The wrong kind of man
Why moral imperfection does not automatically erase historical purpose.
Forbidden America presents · A book by Juan Badillo
CHOSEN?
Donald Trump, providence, and the biblical pattern of the imperfect instrument.
First edition · 198 pages · ISBN 978-0-557-95739-2
NOWAVAILABLE
PROVIDENCE ★ POWER ★ JERUSALEM ★ BUTLER ★ DEFEAT ★ RETURN ★ WHO KNOWS? PERHAPS ★ PROVIDENCE ★ POWER ★ JERUSALEM ★ BUTLER ★ DEFEAT ★ RETURN ★ WHO KNOWS? PERHAPS ★
Could God use
the wrong kind of man?
Not: Is Donald Trump perfect? He isn’t.
Not: Does the Bible predict Donald Trump? This book finds no persuasive evidence that it does.
The harder question: Could his political life fit a biblical pattern in which providence works through deeply imperfect instruments?
July 13, 2024 · Butler, Pennsylvania
Where the book beginsA story that could have ended
A story that could have ended
did not end.
Donald Trump survived an assassination attempt. Months later, the former president who lost in 2020 won 312 electoral votes and returned to the White House.
History can establish what happened. It cannot observe providence like a visible mechanism. Somewhere between Butler and the return, an ancient question followed him.
“Belief is not proof. But the question is too consequential to dismiss—and too dangerous to approach without evidence, humility, and a serious case against itself.”
— CHOSEN?The case.
The objections.
The reckoning.
The pagan messiah
Cyrus, the outsider called anointed—and the limits of the comparison.
Jerusalem
A documented decision, a theological interpretation, and the line between them.
Three justices
Political consequence, constitutional change, and competing moral judgments.
Defeat & wilderness
Why a providential argument must confront 2020 instead of explaining it away.
Butler & the return
Survival, victory, and the question history cannot answer for us.
What if I’m wrong?
The strongest case against the book’s own thesis gets its day in court.
Who knows? Perhaps.
Conviction without certainty. Belief without pretending it is proof.
The biblical patternUse is not
Use is not
endorsement.
Cyrus did not know Israel’s God. Nebuchadnezzar was called a servant. David was chosen and still accountable. Samson was called and chaotic.
The existence of that category does not prove Donald Trump belongs in it. It makes the question possible—and demands that the comparison survive scrutiny.
CYRUSDAVIDSAMSONESTHERTRUMP?
No hidden leap.
No prophecy claim
Isaiah did not secretly predict an American president.
No numerology
Isaiah 45 and the 45th president is trivia—not evidence.
No moral blank check
Possible instrumentality never excuses wrongdoing.
No untouchable thesis
A theory that explains every outcome proves nothing.
No party requirement
The reader is invited to examine, challenge, and decide.
FORBIDDEN AMERICA · FIRST EDITION · 2026 ·The book is publishedHistory happened.
History happened.
Meaning is the question.
198 pages. Seventeen chapters. Notes and sources. One question the reader must answer.
Buy CHOSEN? on Lulu ISBN 978-0-557-95739-2Contact Forbidden AmericaStart a
Start a
conversation.
Questions about CHOSEN?, interview requests, speaking opportunities, events, and thoughtful disagreement are welcome.